Is the highest offer always the best offer in a multiple offer situation?

For those of you looking for a quick answer, the answer is a resounding no!  For those of you wondering why, read on!

There are many important components to an offer, and price is only one of them! First is financial ability to perform.  An offer is worth nothing if the buyer is unable to pay for the home.  A cash offer with proof of funds is your best bet, but most buyers take mortgages.  If the offer is contingent upon the buyer getting a mortgage, make sure you receive a pre-approval letter from a local, well-reputed lender (and not an internet lender).

Second, make sure you receive a substantial amount of hand money.  Hand money is all you have if a buyer backs out of the deal. Sometimes buyers just change their minds.  Maybe a house they like better comes on the market.  Maybe they figure out that the home needs more work thab they originally imagined and the remodeling costs get too high.  Maybe they take a new job that is too far from your home.  There are many reasons why buyers change their minds and if you lose your buyer, you will want to be sure you have a decent amount of hand money to compensate you for the loss.

Finally, some buyers will offer more for a home with the expectation that they will “beat you up on your home inspection.”  Your best line of defense against these tactics is to make sure that you have been exceptionally thorough in your disclosure so that there is nothing (or almost nothing) wrong that you haven’t already told them about.  A pre-inspection is a great way to make sure that your home is in great shape and that all issues are disclosed – it will save you money in the long run.  Some buyers will even waive inspections if you provide a pre-inspection from a quality home inspector, which is the best scenario of all!

63 Thorn Street

Expertly remodeled, 63 Thorn paints a modern landscape on a charming traditional palate to create an exceptional home. Sited on a large lot with fully fenced back yard. The expertly designed and crafted kitchen (which is open to the family room) is flooded with light from an entire wall of windows that bring the private backyard into this warm and inviting space.  The dining room has also been opened to the back yard through an impressive wall of windows and doors, and spills effortless out onto the new back deck.  The second level is home to a new master suite with large closet and spa-like private bath.  Four additional bedrooms, two full baths and a convenient second floor laundry room complete the upper levels.  Please join us for our open house this Sunday! $1,450,000  See more…


439 Oliver

Located in one of Sewickley’s most sought after neighborhoods, once inside you will be surprised how big this home is!  Beautifully remodeled, it offers three spacious finished levels of living space, including a main level bedroom suite! The newer kitchen is open to both the dining area and large family room. Walls of windows overlook the beautiful backyard – French doors open to the private patio. A convenient mudroom provides access to the attached garage. The lower level includes a finished game room, full bath, fifth bedroom and a spacious storage/mechanics/laundry area. Close proximity to all village amenities and schools. Freshly painted interior…move in and enjoy all that Sewickley has to offer. Please join us for our open house this Sunday! $675,000  See More….


I’m ready to answer any questions you have regarding your real estate needs.
Kathe Barge, CRS, ABR, CNE, SRES
Associate Broker
401 Broad Street
Sewickley, PA 15143
Cell: 412-779-6060
Office: 412-741-2200 x238